Alan wrote:SWK, you may not have actually said "right" or "wrong", but you certainly implied it over and over, loud and clear, articulating surfing at a higher level as reasoning. But really you are coming from a "coolness" standpoint rather than performance. Just admit it.
My opinion is that strapless does not allow surfing at a higher level, its just more fun for some (myself included in certain conditions). On a bigger board, it allows more foot movement, which is necessary. On a smaller board, no advantage, just the fun factor.
As for unhooked, I've done it, I rode fixed for years. Its fun and at first feels like it frees up my lower and mid body. But it is limiting. For example, is there anyone in the world who can do a round house cutback upwind unhooked (side shore wind)? Nope. Not even on a super small C kite. On a modern high depower kite hooked in this is no problem.
I actually think that unhooked is the reason good surfers think we look like crap in the waves (they are right). Unhooked riders are often out of position on the wave, either too far ahead of the peak, or too far out in the flats. And once they are out of position, they can't get back against the pull of the kite.
Also, holding the bar restricts arm movement. All good surfers pre-rotate or swing their arms and whole upper body in advance of a powerful turn. This is impossible holding the bar and to me compared to surfing without the bar, feels like counter rotation (in other words, it feels awkward - even more awkward than I am naturally
).
So SWK, how do you propose to get higher performance with those two limiting factors unhooked: Lack of depower and restricted arm movement? Hook back in with a modern kite and see what it feels like to free your WHOLE body and stay in the sweet spot on the wave. Turn as hard as you want when ever the wave dictates, even up wind.
Please don't say to edge hard against the kite to force it to the edge of the window for depower. Edge against the kite while on the wave and you can't feel the wave. I guess its fine if thats your style, just don't call it surfing with a kite. More like wake boarding with a surf board in the waves, slamming into the peak once in a while, spending most of your time edging out in the flats. Thats what I see when I watch videos of unhooked "surfing".
Alan